Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Can our statistics conclusion say library use improved marks when the data only show an association?

Education category photographEducation

My partner changed “went together” to “improved.” It made our conclusion sound more decisive, but I couldn't explain why the stronger word was justified.

Our statistics worksheet uses an invented practice dataset about students' library hours and test marks. In the table, students recording more library time tend to have higher marks. We have no description of an experiment or information about other differences between the students.

The Australian Bureau of Statistics explains that a correlation does not automatically establish that one variable caused a change in another. I think that limits our sentence, even though library study sounds like a plausible explanation.

How should we describe the result without making the whole exercise sound pointless? I want to distinguish what this classroom dataset shows from a possible explanation and from a recommendation somebody might want to test.

Discussion

5 community replies

Use wording that describes the observed association in the practice data. Then discuss possible explanations separately. You can report a pattern without claiming that changing one thing would necessarily change the other.

Perhaps the students differed in other ways, but those are possibilities to investigate, not replacement facts you can announce. Avoid moving from one unsupported causal story to a different one simply because it sounds more cautious.

Your partner may be trying to answer the assignment's request for a conclusion. A careful conclusion is still a conclusion. Show the difference between summarising the table and claiming an effect the exercise has not established.

Ask what further evidence would be needed before making a recommendation based on causation. That could become a useful limitation or next-step sentence, rather than a paragraph apologising for having any data at all.

A next-step sentence would make the limitation productive. You might propose investigating the relationship further, while keeping clear that the supplied data are an invented exercise. The report can demonstrate good reasoning without presenting a classroom pattern as evidence for a real college policy.

Join the discussion

More in Education