Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Can our school newspaper rewrite a hesitant interview answer into a confident quotation?

Education category photographEducation

For the school newspaper, I interviewed the organiser of a proposed garden. In the recording she says it might open next term if enough volunteers come forward. Our draft quote now says it will open next term, with a tidy explanation that she never used in those words.

The editor says we are helping her sound clear and that everyone knows interviews need editing. I agree that printing every pause would make the article awkward, but the new sentence seems more certain than the answer she gave.

Reuters' standards on quotations distinguish limited editing that preserves meaning from rewriting a phrase, and suggest paraphrase where appropriate. They are a useful reference, although our school paper has its own editorial process.

How should I propose a readable correction before the page is finalised?

Discussion

5 community replies

Play back the relevant answer with the editor and compare the meaning, especially might, will and the condition about volunteers. This is more than removing pauses: the draft has changed how certain the opening date sounds.

Offer a concrete alternative in reported speech that preserves the condition, then use a short accurate quotation if it adds something. Readability does not require presenting a sentence the organiser never said as her exact words.

Check the headline and caption as well as the quote. A careful paragraph about a proposed opening will not fix a headline that announces a confirmed date. The same uncertainty should carry through the page.

If the answer is genuinely unclear, ask the supervising teacher how to obtain clarification before publication. A new confirmation could support an updated statement, but you should not quietly treat it as the wording from the original interview.

Agreed. Keep track of what was said in the interview and what was confirmed later, and make the article accurate about both. Asking a follow-up question can resolve uncertainty; it is not a reason to backfill a polished quotation into the earlier exchange.

Join the discussion

More in Education