Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Can my child use her brother's old bicycle helmet if it looks fine after his crash?

Parenting category photographParenting

My nine-year-old wants the blue bicycle helmet her older brother has outgrown. He wore it in a crash last year in which his helmet hit the pavement. It looks intact, and she likes having something that used to be his.

I nearly agreed because the straps can be adjusted. My partner reminded me about the crash. The question is about the equipment now, not assessing anyone's injury from that earlier accident.

The US Consumer Product Safety Commission explains that bicycle helmets are designed for a single crash impact and must be replaced after that impact even if damage is not visible.

How do I explain why this hand-me-down is different from passing on his jacket or bicycle? We need a suitable helmet before she rides; I do not want her to think the refusal means she cannot be trusted with his things.

Discussion

5 community replies

Do not use the crashed bicycle helmet. The CPSC guidance explains why the outside looking intact does not establish that it can protect her in another crash. Adjusting the straps answers a different question.

Tell her the decision comes from the helmet's known history. It says nothing about how carefully she would treat it. Avoid making her offer to be extra cautious as though that could restore the helmet.

Arrange a helmet appropriate for cycling that fits her and meets the applicable requirements, following the manufacturer's fitting guidance. Check both protection and fit; do not make finding another blue helmet the condition for getting a suitable one.

She can still value something that belonged to her brother without using it as safety equipment. Ask whether she wants a photograph or a different appropriate hand-me-down instead.

A photograph could preserve what she likes about the connection while you remove this helmet from the cycling kit. Keep those decisions separate. Saving a memory should not leave a crashed helmet available to be mistaken for the one she is meant to wear.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting