Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Can melted butter do the creaming job my cake recipe asks for?

Food category photographFood

The recipe said softened butter, but I used the microwave until mine was liquid because I thought that would make mixing easier. With the sugar added, it looked wet and grainy. I hadn't reached the eggs or flour when I noticed the next line: beat until light and fluffy.

Is that a texture I can reach by beating this mixture longer, or did melting change the job the butter was meant to do? I can pause before adding the rest. I'd like to understand the method before turning a small shortcut into a whole disappointing cake.

Discussion

5 community replies

King Arthur's creaming guide explains that softened butter needs to hold the air incorporated during beating; butter that's too warm or melted can't do that job properly. Wet and greasy isn't the same endpoint as light and fluffy. More beating alone isn't a reliable repair.

Stop before adding the eggs and flour. The other ingredients are still separate, so you can choose a coherent next step.

Check the recipe's description of softened butter as well as any time estimate. 'Microwave for a bit' gave you a liquid, while the instruction was asking for a particular starting texture.

If you prefer using melted butter, pick a cake recipe written for it next time. There's nothing wrong with wanting a simpler mixing method.

Exactly. That preference can guide the recipe choice before you start. It doesn't make this recipe's creaming step optional, and it doesn't require you to buy a more powerful mixer to force liquid butter into the expected result.

Join the discussion

More in Food