Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Can I write a negative review of the novel our tutor chose?

Education category photographEducation

I finished the novel and disliked the ending. Our review brief asks us to make a judgment and support it with passages, but a friend said it would be safer to praise the book because the tutor chose it.

I started writing that the ending was “powerful,” then stopped. I do not believe that, and I cannot explain why it would be true. What I can explain is that an earlier conflict seemed to disappear rather than be resolved.

How can I make that criticism fair and useful? I do not want to turn “I disliked it” into an unsupported verdict, but I also do not want my review to pretend I had the response I think the tutor wants.

Discussion

5 community replies

Use the conflict you identified as the starting point. Show where the novel establishes it and what happens to it at the end. That gives the reader something to assess beyond your reaction.

Describe what the ending appears to attempt before judging whether it succeeds. You can question an unresolved ending while considering whether leaving the conflict open might have been a deliberate choice.

You do not need to insert praise you cannot support. If another part worked well, discuss what it contributes; if it is irrelevant to your central judgment, a compulsory compliment would only distract from the review.

Consider the strongest alternative reading of the ending. What might another reader point to as evidence that the conflict remains meaningfully open? Address that passage rather than assume there is only one reasonable response.

That alternative can sharpen your criticism. You might acknowledge what the passage does, then explain why it still does not resolve the particular problem you identified. Disagreement supported by the novel fits the brief you described better than an invented claim that you found it powerful.

Join the discussion

More in Education