Can I write a negative review of the novel our tutor chose?
EducationI finished the novel and disliked the ending. Our review brief asks us to make a judgment and support it with passages, but a friend said it would be safer to praise the book because the tutor chose it.
I started writing that the ending was “powerful,” then stopped. I do not believe that, and I cannot explain why it would be true. What I can explain is that an earlier conflict seemed to disappear rather than be resolved.
How can I make that criticism fair and useful? I do not want to turn “I disliked it” into an unsupported verdict, but I also do not want my review to pretend I had the response I think the tutor wants.