Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Can I try approximate location for a weather app instead of granting precise access?

Technology category photographTechnology

A weather app on my Android phone requested precise location. I mainly open it to look at the forecast for my town, and the permission screen offers approximate location too.

Google documents separate controls for location access and for whether an app can use precise location. Android location-permission guidance

Would you try the narrower option and check the features you use, or consult the app's guidance first? I don't want to assume every weather app works identically, but I also don't want the first permission request to decide the amount of access without a question.

Discussion

5 community replies

Check the options on your device and try approximate access if that fits your purpose. Google's guidance describes turning precise location on or off for an app with location permission. That establishes an available control, not a promise about this app's functionality. Location settings

Precision and timing are separate choices. Review whether the app has access only while you use it, asks each time where supported, or has broader access. Choosing approximate location doesn't by itself answer when access is allowed. Permission options

Consult the app's explanation of the feature requesting precision. It may clarify a function you aren't using or reveal that your preferred workflow needs a different setup. You can decide from that explanation without declaring all precise-location requests unreasonable.

Check whether the town and functions you actually use remain available after the change. Keep the comparison focused on your purpose, rather than testing unrelated features just because the app offers them.

If the app refuses the narrower option, that leaves a choice about its benefit and requested access. A manual place selection, if offered, may be another route. Don't assume refusal proves precision was necessary for every part of the service.

Join the discussion

More in Technology