Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Can I take away a reward already earned for a different mistake?

Parenting category photographParenting

My nine-year-old earned the final sticker on his bag-packing chart and got to choose Saturday's family game. Later he spoke sharply to me during a disagreement. I wiped off that day's sticker and said he no longer had the full set.

He asked whether his bag had somehow become unpacked. The chart was for preparing it for school; I hadn't said stickers could be removed for unrelated behaviour. My partner thinks an unpleasant response still needs a consequence and that keeping the reward would send the wrong message.

I want to address how he spoke without implying that completing the original task now counts for nothing. Would you restore the sticker and deal with the exchange separately, or keep the removal and make the condition clearer next time? I can see I used the chart because it was a convenient thing to take away while I was annoyed.

Discussion

5 community replies

His question about the bag goes straight to the arrangement you made. The task was completed. I would restore the sticker and say you changed its meaning in the middle of another argument.

You can still revisit what he said and what happened between you. Restoring a chart entry doesn't require declaring the sharp response acceptable. Have that conversation about the exchange itself, rather than making him repeat a task he already did.

It matters that there wasn't an existing removal condition. Don't make him prove he remembered the rules more accurately than you before you acknowledge that. You already know what you originally offered.

If you revise the chart for the future, be careful about turning a defined task into a test of being agreeable all day. Then neither of you can tell what has actually been earned until every later conversation is over.

Yes. Clearer future rules shouldn't simply mean announcing that any mistake can erase the whole week. Decide what the chart is for, and keep other problems attached to an appropriate conversation or response of their own.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting