Can I stop doing my RPG character's theatrical voice halfway through the campaign?
GamingI introduced my character with a grand, booming voice, and everyone loved it. Several sessions later, I spend so much attention maintaining the performance that I sometimes miss what another character is asking. I'd rather speak normally and keep the same character.
When I tried that for one scene, a friend asked for 'the proper voice.' They sounded disappointed, not hostile, and I went back to performing. How do I explain that the joke worked as an entrance but isn't how I want to spend every session? I don't want to invent a story reason for changing something about how I play.