Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Can I stay in a friends' savings challenge without posting the same target as everyone else?

Money category photographMoney

A friend suggested that we each save the same amount every month and post our progress in a group chat. Using illustrative figures, the target is $300. I initially said it sounded motivating, then worked through my budget and found that $80 was the amount I could set aside comfortably.

I want the encouragement, but I don't want every month to become an explanation of why my number is smaller. My friend says the shared target is what makes it a challenge. I haven't agreed to move money from bills or other commitments to reach it.

How would you suggest a version I can join honestly, or step back without making her idea sound foolish?

Discussion

5 community replies

'I can save $80 and would like encouragement with that' is a clear starting point. The amount comes from your budget. You don't need the group to certify that budget before you can choose a target.

Could the check-in be about keeping each person's own commitment rather than matching deposits? Ask whether that would still be enjoyable for the others. They can prefer a fixed-target challenge, and you can prefer a different arrangement.

You can also keep the numbers private and share a small progress update if the group is comfortable with that. The useful part for you may be remembering the goal, not displaying a balance every month.

A challenge is supposed to stretch people. If everyone chooses an amount they already find comfortable, it may lose the thing your friend was trying to create.

Stretch can be a choice, but the same dollar target doesn't tell you what anyone can spare. Your friend can keep her version without you promising money already assigned elsewhere. Offer the form of participation you actually want; if it doesn't fit, stepping back is a reasonable outcome.

Join the discussion

More in Money