Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Can I replace the gelatin with agar in marshmallows for a vegetarian friend?

Food category photographFood

I offered to make marshmallows for our hot-chocolate evening, then noticed the gelatin in the recipe. One friend is vegetarian. I haven't bought the ingredients, and she's said she'd enjoy a different topping just as much, but I'd still like to make something she can share.

I found agar beside the baking ingredients and nearly assumed I could use the same quantity. King Arthur's gelatin guide explains gelatin's animal origin and describes trials with plant-based substitutes: the author found marshmallows harder to get right than some softer desserts. That makes me wary of borrowing a conversion intended for a different dish.

Would you choose a marshmallow recipe developed for the particular substitute, do a trial before the evening, or switch toppings? I don't want my friend cast as the reason an ambitious dessert didn't work.

Discussion

5 community replies

Choose a recipe developed for the gelling ingredient you intend to use. 'Both set a liquid' doesn't tell you that they'll produce the same marshmallow texture in the same amount. You already have time to choose the method before shopping.

Her offer of a different topping sounds like useful information, not polite permission you have to overcome. Ask what she'd actually enjoy. Making her part of the choice may feel more welcoming than presenting a difficult project done on her behalf.

A trial is sensible if you want to learn, but decide what happens if it fails before starting. Otherwise the evening can become a deadline for repeating the experiment.

I'd still try the marshmallows. Discovering a new technique can be part of the fun, as long as you aren't asking the friend to praise whatever result you get.

Then make the experiment your project, and have the agreed topping ready either way. 'I wanted to learn this' puts the responsibility in the right place. Nobody needs to hear that accommodating their food choice caused hours of trouble.

Join the discussion

More in Food