Can I replace the gelatin with agar in marshmallows for a vegetarian friend?
FoodI offered to make marshmallows for our hot-chocolate evening, then noticed the gelatin in the recipe. One friend is vegetarian. I haven't bought the ingredients, and she's said she'd enjoy a different topping just as much, but I'd still like to make something she can share.
I found agar beside the baking ingredients and nearly assumed I could use the same quantity. King Arthur's gelatin guide explains gelatin's animal origin and describes trials with plant-based substitutes: the author found marshmallows harder to get right than some softer desserts. That makes me wary of borrowing a conversion intended for a different dish.
Would you choose a marshmallow recipe developed for the particular substitute, do a trial before the evening, or switch toppings? I don't want my friend cast as the reason an ambitious dessert didn't work.