Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Can I release a new version of the song I wrote with my former bandmate?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

I want to record an acoustic version of a song from our old band. I wrote the lyrics and my former bandmate wrote the melody. We're in the UK. I initially thought a fresh recording would be entirely my project because I wouldn't be using the band's recorded track.

Then I realised I'd still be singing the melody they wrote. We never made a clear written ownership agreement, and I haven't reread our old messages about the song. We parted awkwardly, so I'd been hoping to send them a finished version rather than start a difficult conversation.

The UK Intellectual Property Office's ownership guidance distinguishes music, lyrics and recordings, and explains that ownership depends on the circumstances. It doesn't establish our particular rights or permissions from this short account.

What should I clarify before planning a release, and how do I approach my former bandmate without presenting a completed project as something they have to accept?

Discussion

5 community replies

Speak to them before announcing or distributing the new version. Describe what you want to make and acknowledge their melody, instead of opening with a finished recording and a request to approve what is already happening.

First gather the old messages and any agreements you can find. An awkward memory of how the band ended isn't a reliable account of what you agreed about this song.

Keep the practical permission question separate from reopening the whole friendship. You can make a courteous, specific enquiry without requiring either of you to settle the history of the band.

If the ownership or scope of permission remains unclear, get appropriate UK copyright advice before releasing it. Don't settle the uncertainty by assigning yourselves shares that merely seem fair now.

Agreed. You can discuss terms you both might accept, but that is different from assuming those terms already exist. A new recording alone doesn't answer the question about using the underlying song.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment