Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

Can I refuse to lend one particular book to a friend who treats books differently?

Relationships category photographRelationships

My friend pulled my grandfather's cookbook from the shelf and said, "Can I borrow this for the weekend?" I hesitated. He'd written notes in the margins, and I'd kept the little paper bookmarks he made.

She borrows other books from me. The last one came back with several folded page corners. She apologised when I mentioned it, but also said books were meant to be used. I agree about my ordinary paperbacks. This one matters to me for reasons beyond reading it.

She offered to be especially careful. I said I'd think about it because refusing felt like announcing that I didn't trust her. Now she has asked again. Should I explain the history and keep it at home, or give her a chance to show that she understands the difference? I don't want an object to become an argument about what sort of friend she is.

Discussion

2 community replies

Keep the explanation attached to this book: "It's the one with my grandfather's notes, and I don't lend it out." That is an understandable limit on an object that matters to you. You don't need to make a wider claim that she can never be trusted with anything.

Her offer to be careful may be sincere. You can recognise that without accepting it: "I believe you'd try. I'd still rather keep this one here." Refusing a loan doesn't have to mean you think she intends to damage it.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships