Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Can I move a non-flexible cash ISA by withdrawing it into my current account first?

Money category photographMoney

I want to move a UK cash ISA to another provider. My existing provider says this account is not flexible. I was about to withdraw the balance into my ordinary current account and pay it into the new ISA, because that looked faster than filling in a transfer form.

My partner asked whether 'moving the same money' was enough to preserve its ISA treatment. I haven't made the withdrawal. Some of the balance was saved in earlier tax years, and I haven't checked how much new allowance I've used this year.

Which parts of this move need to go through the providers rather than through my own bank transfer?

Discussion

5 community replies

GOV.UK's ISA transfer guidance directs you to the new provider's ISA transfer process. It warns that withdrawing the money yourself can lose the ability to reinvest that part of the tax-free allowance. Check the formal route before taking it out.

Confirm that the new provider accepts the transfer and ask both providers about restrictions or charges on this particular account. A transfer form isn't proof that every proposed destination or account term works the same way.

Keep the earlier-years balance and this year's subscriptions clear in the discussion. The current account would simply receive cash; it wouldn't label a later payment into the new ISA as a provider-to-provider transfer.

If the balance is smaller than the annual allowance, couldn't you just withdraw and pay it in again without worrying about the distinction?

That still requires checking the allowance already used and the account rules, and it isn't the same transaction as an ISA transfer. Your account is stated to be non-flexible. Have the providers confirm the treatment before assuming the size of the balance makes the route irrelevant.

Join the discussion

More in Money