Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Can I give useful peer feedback when I cannot suggest a better way to write the passage?

Education category photographEducation

My workshop partner usually gets stronger writing feedback than I do. We have been asked to exchange drafts, and I nearly wrote “all good” on hers because I felt unqualified to criticise it.

There is one paragraph where I could not tell who “they” referred to. I reread it and am still unsure, but I do not know the best way to rewrite the sentence. She has not dismissed my feedback; I have barely given her any.

What could I say that would be useful? I can describe where I got lost. I am less sure whether that counts if I cannot supply the fix.

Discussion

5 community replies

Point to the sentence and explain the two possible people or groups you thought 'they' might mean. That gives your partner a precise reader response, even without a replacement sentence.

Her stronger marks do not tell you how every sentence will read to someone else. The workshop asks you to engage with this draft. 'All good' would conceal the one thing you actually noticed.

Check the nearby sentences before raising it, as you have begun doing. You can still present it as a question about the reference rather than declare that the paragraph is definitely wrong. She may explain an intentional choice or notice an ambiguity.

Ask which kind of response would help her most: where the argument is clear, where you lose the thread, or another focus from the workshop prompt. You do not have to take responsibility for rewriting the whole piece.

If she asks you for a fix, you can explain what a revision would need to make clear and let her choose the wording. That keeps the feedback specific while leaving the writing decision with its author.

Join the discussion

More in Education