Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Can I bring a different dish after my family has assigned me potato salad again?

Food category photographFood

I brought potato salad to three family gatherings because people liked it. This time my aunt sent the food list with my name beside potato salad before asking what I'd like to make. I'd already been thinking about a roast-vegetable dish.

I'm pleased they enjoyed the salad, but I don't want liking it to turn into a permanent assignment. My aunt is trying to get a familiar meal organised, and I haven't told her I'm bored with making it.

How do I ask to change my contribution without making the compliment sound unwelcome?

Discussion

5 community replies

Reply while the list is still being organised: 'I'm glad everyone liked it. I'd like to bring roast vegetables this time; can we change my entry?' That separates appreciation from agreeing to make it again.

The list may be her shortcut based on what worked before. She needs to hear your preference before she can know that the familiar assignment has stopped being convenient for you.

Don't promise the salad and hope enthusiasm for your alternative changes the plan later. Say which dish you're offering before anyone shops around an assumed commitment.

What if she has already planned the rest of the meal around that salad?

Then ask what changing it would actually affect. You might choose to help with this gathering after that discussion, but a specific accommodation now needn't become a standing promise for every family meal.

Join the discussion

More in Food