Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Can I ask to stay in the orchestra's rehearsals without playing concerts?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

I joined a community orchestra because I wanted to play with other people again. The part I love is working through a passage at rehearsal and hearing it gradually come together.

The concert is different. I spend the weeks before it worrying about the performance, and I no longer want that part of the activity. I told a friend I might ask to attend rehearsals without playing the concerts. She said that would mean taking the enjoyable part while leaving everyone else to deliver the show.

I haven't asked the organiser yet. I don't know whether rehearsal-only participation fits how this orchestra works, and I don't want to announce a personal exemption as though it's already been agreed. Is there a fair way to make the request, or should I look for a group whose whole purpose is informal playing?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask about the arrangement rather than claiming the place. Explain what you enjoy and what you no longer want to commit to, then let the organiser tell you whether rehearsals and concerts can be separated in this group.

Your friend's concern could matter if the section is relying on you for the concert. It doesn't establish that every orchestra must have the same policy. Find out what your absence would mean for this particular group before deciding that the request itself is unfair.

Be clear about the next concert as well as future membership. Are you already expected to play it, and how much notice can you give? An honest conversation now is more considerate than staying vague until the organiser builds plans around your attendance.

An informal playing group might give you more of what you want, rather than feeling like the consolation prize for leaving concerts behind. If this orchestra needs everyone to take part in performances, that would be a reason to look for a different arrangement, rather than force yourself to want the concerts.

That possibility could make the conversation less defensive. You can ask whether there is room for your preference while accepting that the answer may be no. Then looking elsewhere would be a practical fit, rather than a punishment for not wanting to perform.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment