Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

Can I ask my brother to leave my childhood nickname out of his speech?

Relationships category photographRelationships

My brother sent me the opening of his speech for my graduation dinner: "We never thought little Disaster would get here." Disaster was the nickname he gave me after I broke a cake stand when I was nine. I'm thirty now, and I've asked him twice in the past year to stop using it around my friends.

I replied that I loved the bit about us revising at the kitchen table, but wanted the nickname and that first line removed. He said, "It's affectionate. You used to laugh." He's right that I did. Sometimes it was funny, and sometimes laughing was easier than explaining why I hated it.

He helped me practise my final presentation and is proud of me. I asked him to speak because I wanted that history in the room. I don't want to replace him over one sentence, but I don't want to spend the dinner smiling through an introduction that makes me feel nine again.

How firmly can I put this without turning the whole speech into something he has to submit for approval?

Discussion

2 community replies

You already gave him a specific change and a part you liked. I'd repeat the request without arguing over whether the nickname was ever affectionate: 'I know you mean it warmly. I don't want Disaster used at this dinner. Please tell the kitchen-table story instead.' He still has plenty of room to write his own speech.

'We never thought you'd get here' would bother me even without the nickname. It makes the achievement sound like a surprise to the family. Is that actually the story he intends to tell, or is he reaching for an easy opening joke? Ask him what he wants your guests to understand about you.

Join the discussion