Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Can I ask a player to use a dice tray after their rolls keep scattering the board?

Gaming category photographGaming

The dice hit a row of miniatures for the second time, and we stopped to reconstruct their positions from memory. The player rolling them laughed, then looked embarrassed when I suggested using the empty tray beside the board.

They like rolling across the table and thought the suggestion meant we didn't trust their dice. I was thinking about the pieces, not the numbers. We haven't agreed on a rolling area, so I don't want the new request to sound like a personal punishment.

How would you make room for an enjoyable roll without repeatedly having to rebuild the position?

Discussion

5 community replies

Name the actual problem: pieces are being moved by the dice. A tray or a clear rolling area addresses that without making a claim about whether the rolls are honest.

Apply the arrangement to everyone, including your own rolls. That makes it a practical table setup rather than a special restriction announced whenever one person reaches for their dice.

Let the player try the tray and say whether they can comfortably see and use it. If it doesn't suit the table, an agreed clear area may be a better option than arguing that one particular accessory is mandatory.

Agree how to handle dice that leave the rolling area before the next important roll. You don't want the first disagreement about a favourable result to become the moment you invent the rule.

Yes, and agree it without trying to reconstruct whether earlier rolls would have counted. The useful change is a predictable arrangement for the next roll, not a retrospective contest over everyone's luck.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming