Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Can failed rolls make my RPG character unsuccessful without making them look incompetent?

Gaming category photographGaming

My veteran archer missed an attack, and the GM described them forgetting which end of the bow to point forward. Everyone laughed, including me. After several similar descriptions, I started avoiding the skills I'd chosen to make the character good at.

I'm happy for attacks to miss and plans to fail. What bothers me is the running picture of someone who can't manage their own equipment. How do I ask for a different flavour of failure without sounding as though I want immunity from bad results? The GM enjoys comic narration and may not realise I've stopped enjoying this particular joke.

Discussion

5 community replies

Use the bow example and separate the result from the description: 'I'm fine with missing. Could the miss sometimes show a good defence or a difficult situation rather than forgetting how to use the bow?'

Your early laughter may have looked like encouragement. You can explain that the repeated version landed differently without claiming the GM should have known immediately.

A capable character can meet capable opposition. Discuss a few kinds of description you both enjoy, while keeping whatever mechanical consequences your game calls for.

The other players may enjoy comic failures, so this needn't become a ban on humour at the table. Ask about the treatment of your character rather than prescribing everyone else's preferred tone.

That leaves room for different tastes. A quick check about who enjoys which kind of joke could help the GM vary the narration, without making your character incapable of ever having an awkward moment.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming