Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Can evaporated milk replace the sweetened condensed milk in my dessert?

Food category photographFood

I reached for the tin and found I'd bought evaporated milk. The dessert recipe calls for sweetened condensed milk. Both tins were together on the shelf, and I hadn't read beyond the word milk.

I haven't opened it or started mixing. Is this a straightforward substitution, or should I get the named ingredient and save this tin for another recipe? I don't want to guess a sugar adjustment and discover that sweetness wasn't the only thing the original ingredient contributed.

Discussion

5 community replies

They aren't interchangeable tins of the same product. Carnation's explanation distinguishes evaporated milk from sweetened condensed milk, which has added sugar and is thick and sweet. I'd use the named ingredient or an adaptation written for evaporated milk, rather than assume a spoonful of sugar makes them equivalent.

Leave the tin unopened while you decide. A different purchase is easier than an improvised recipe repair.

What dessert are you making? Without the rest of the formula and method, a confident substitution ratio would be guesswork. The ingredient may be doing more than one job.

If going back to the shop is awkward, choose a different dessert from ingredients you already have. You haven't made the first step a commitment to finish this particular one.

Yes. Check the complete alternative recipe before opening the tin, so the replacement plan doesn't reveal another missing ingredient halfway through. Changing dessert should make the evening easier, not start another chain of guesses.

Join the discussion

More in Food