Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Can buying a replacement make it all right for my child to keep a library book?

Parenting category photographParenting

My eight-year-old has become attached to a library book that is due back on Friday. He asked to keep it and use his savings to buy the library another copy. I first thought that sounded like a generous solution.

We have not asked the library whether they would accept that arrangement. The book is intact; he has not lost or damaged it. He simply wants this copy to become his, and I do not want to treat a replacement offer as permission we can give ourselves.

I would like to encourage his enjoyment of the book. I also want him to understand what we agreed when we borrowed it without turning a favourite story into a lesson delivered as a scolding.

What should we ask the librarian, and what do we do while we wait for an answer? I have not promised to buy a copy for home or to let him spend money on replacing something the library may still expect us to return.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the existing arrangement: this copy was borrowed and has a return date. Offering something in exchange is a request to the library, not a decision you and your son can complete by yourselves.

Ask the librarian about the actual options, including a renewal or whether they can suggest a way to find a personal copy. Do not promise either is available; other readers or the library's own arrangements may affect the answer.

Let him describe why he loves this particular book. You can note its title and talk about the story without treating keeping the physical copy as the only way his enjoyment counts.

Keep Friday's return plan unless the library confirms a different arrangement. Waiting for an answer does not itself extend the loan.

Put the book with the things to take back and explain that you can still ask your question at the desk. Returning it as agreed will not prevent you discussing future borrowing. Avoid presenting a purchase you have made in advance as a reason the librarian must accept the exchange.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting