Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Can a tooltip be the only place visitors find our upload rules?

Technology category photographTechnology

Our photo-challenge page keeps the file requirements inside a little question-mark tooltip. It looks neat on my desktop. A volunteer using the keyboard couldn't reach the explanation, and another couldn't find it on their phone.

The designer wants to keep the form short. W3C's guidance discusses making content shown on hover or focus perceivable and manageable, including when it stays visible and how it can be dismissed. W3C hover-and-focus guidance

Would you put the essential requirements beside the upload field and keep the tooltip for extra help? I want people to choose a valid file without first discovering a hidden interaction.

Discussion

5 community replies

Put the information needed to complete the upload where people can find it while choosing the file. Keeping the page short is useful, but hiding a necessary instruction can make the apparent simplicity depend on already knowing the answer.

If a tooltip remains, check its interaction against the guidance rather than merely whether it appears with your mouse. W3C discusses persistence, moving the pointer onto the extra content, and dismissal where applicable. Hover-and-focus requirements

Separate essentials from explanation. A brief statement of accepted file requirements beside the field may be enough there; a longer example can live in additional help. That gives the designer a way to preserve a compact form without concealing the core instruction.

Test the revised page with the actual keyboard and phone interactions that failed. Ask the volunteers to find the requirements and attempt the intended task, rather than telling them which hidden control to use.

Keep the mouse check as well, especially if the extra content covers another control. Fixing one route shouldn't be assumed to settle the others. The useful result is that each visitor can read the instruction and continue, not simply that the icon now reacts to another gesture.

Join the discussion

More in Technology