Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Another player polished my character's campaign diary and changed how the character sounds

Gaming category photographGaming

My campaign-journal entry said, 'I ran because I was scared.' Another player edited it to, 'I withdrew to preserve the party's tactical position.' They fixed some spelling too and said they were making the shared journal read more smoothly.

The second sentence sounds grander, but admitting fear was the point of my entry. We had agreed that everyone could tidy the journal; I hadn't thought to distinguish corrections from rewriting a character's account of what happened.

How should we handle editing in a shared campaign journal? I want help with obvious errors without having each character's voice polished into the same confident narrator.

Discussion

5 community replies

Explain the change in meaning using those two sentences. This is easier to discuss than a general objection to editing: the frightened retreat became a calculated decision, and that wasn't the character you were writing.

The other player may have understood 'tidy' more broadly than you did. Ask for the original wording back without assuming they were deliberately trying to erase an admission.

Different voices can belong in the same journal. You could distinguish an agreed group recap from entries written in each character's voice, instead of require every section to sound like one official account.

Would comments or suggested wording work better for changes beyond spelling? The person writing the character could then accept help without losing the sentence before they have seen the proposal.

That would preserve both the offer and the choice. Make it easy to decline a suggestion too; otherwise approving edits becomes another way to pressure everyone into the same voice.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming