Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Housing · Advice & Questions ·

An online estimate puts our equity above 20%. Can we stop paying PMI?

Housing category photographHousing

An online home-value estimate has risen enough that my partner thinks we should be able to remove the private mortgage insurance from our US conventional loan. He wants to lower next month's payment himself and tell the servicer why.

We have a single-family home as our main residence, and our documents call the charge PMI. We have not requested cancellation or checked which value and balance the relevant rules use. The CFPB explains a borrower-requested route based on 80% of the home's original value, with conditions, and distinguishes it from automatic termination.

What should we ask the servicer before relying on appreciation as a way to end the charge? I would like to explore a possible saving without assuming a website estimate has already changed our payment obligation.

Discussion

5 community replies

Get the PMI disclosure, current principal balance and applicable original value from the servicer. Ask which cancellation or termination route applies to the loan. Do not start with a percentage calculated from an online estimate and assume it is the percentage used by the rule.

The CFPB guidance also notes that some investors or servicers allow other cancellation standards. Ask whether a current-value route exists, what conditions apply and what valuation evidence it requires. Appreciation may be relevant without making cancellation automatic.

Ask about any valuation fee before commissioning an appraisal yourself. You need to know what evidence the servicer accepts and whether other conditions remain. A paid report would not help if it is not accepted for the process you are trying to use.

Keep making the required payment until the servicer confirms a change. A cancellation request and a lower payment amount are different stages.

Get the effective date and revised payment instructions in writing if cancellation is approved, then check the following statement. That lets you claim any confirmed saving without turning an unresolved request into a short payment.

Join the discussion

More in Housing