Am I making my birthday present a guessing test when my child asks what I would like?
ParentingMy ten-year-old showed me a book and a scarf he was considering for my birthday, both within the small gift budget we'd already agreed. He asked which I would like. I said, "If I choose it myself, it doesn't really count as a thoughtful present."
He put the pictures away and asked my partner to decide instead. My partner says he'd noticed that I like reading and often borrow a scarf, so there was thought behind both options. I was hoping for the pleasure of opening something he chose, but my answer seems to have made choosing feel riskier.
I don't need either item, and I wouldn't want him spending more to get it right. I do enjoy surprises. Is there a way to explain that preference without making him responsible for guessing exactly what will please me? I want him to learn about choosing gifts, but not feel that asking a sensible question cancels the care he has already shown.