Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Am I making my birthday present a guessing test when my child asks what I would like?

Parenting category photographParenting

My ten-year-old showed me a book and a scarf he was considering for my birthday, both within the small gift budget we'd already agreed. He asked which I would like. I said, "If I choose it myself, it doesn't really count as a thoughtful present."

He put the pictures away and asked my partner to decide instead. My partner says he'd noticed that I like reading and often borrow a scarf, so there was thought behind both options. I was hoping for the pleasure of opening something he chose, but my answer seems to have made choosing feel riskier.

I don't need either item, and I wouldn't want him spending more to get it right. I do enjoy surprises. Is there a way to explain that preference without making him responsible for guessing exactly what will please me? I want him to learn about choosing gifts, but not feel that asking a sensible question cancels the care he has already shown.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell him what you can already see: he chose two possibilities connected to things you enjoy. Asking which would be useful is another way of paying attention. Your first answer made the asking itself sound like a mistake, so that is the part I'd correct.

You can give a real answer now: "I'd enjoy either, but the scarf would be especially useful. I spoke too sharply when you asked." Don't make him go through your partner to retrieve information you are willing to give him.

The agreed budget should stay the budget. I'd explicitly say that he doesn't need to add another item or spend extra to restore the surprise. You can still be pleased to unwrap the thing he chose after an ordinary conversation about it.

Enjoying surprises is a preference you can share, too. For another occasion, you might offer several ideas you would like and let him choose among them. He would have useful guidance while you still wouldn't know the exact gift.

That works if the ideas really are welcome options. If you then mark him down for picking the most obvious one, the hidden test is back. For this birthday, I'd accept that he's asked directly and answer, rather than making him restart the whole choice to create a surprise.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting