Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

A timeline error breaks my story's twist, and I don't want to let the twist go

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

Someone in my writing group noticed that my narrator arrives in town on Tuesday, while the final reveal depends on them witnessing an exchange there on Monday. I meant both dates to be in the same week. There isn't a hidden earlier visit.

I started explaining that the reader was supposed to work it out, then realised the draft doesn't give them a way to do that. My favourite final paragraph depends on this reveal.

Moving the arrival back a day would also change why the narrator missed an important meeting. I could rewrite those earlier scenes, or keep the arrival and find a different ending. Neither is just correcting one word, which is what I'd hoped when the mistake was pointed out.

How do I decide what to rebuild without making my favourite paragraph the thing every other part of the story has to protect?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start by acknowledging the dates are inconsistent as written. You can then discuss repair options with the group without asking them to defend their reading of a problem you've also recognised.

What matters to you about the ending besides the surprise? If it's the narrator's choice or a changed relationship, you may be able to preserve that effect with a different route to it.

List what changes under each repair before rewriting whole scenes. Moving the arrival and replacing the reveal may have different costs that are hard to compare while you're only looking at the final paragraph.

Save the paragraph separately while you try another ending. That lets you explore without treating the first experiment as a decision to destroy the version you loved.

Keeping it somewhere also means you don't have to put it back just to avoid losing the wording. Compare what each ending does for this story, including the earlier scenes it requires.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment