Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

A teammate wants me to give the captain a false reason for his absence. How do I stay out of it?

Sports category photographSports

A teammate has decided to skip Saturday's match for a private social plan. He told me because we were discussing the weekend, then asked me to tell the captain he was ill if anyone asked. He hasn't sent his availability message yet.

I don't want to make up an illness. I also don't think it is my job to announce his actual plans to the team. There are enough players if the captain knows in time, so the practical problem is getting an accurate availability answer rather than investigating whether his weekend is important enough.

When I said he should contact the captain himself, he joked that teammates are supposed to cover for each other. I don't want to turn this into a public lesson about honesty, but I don't want to be used as confirmation for a story I know is false. What should I say to him now, and what can I say if the captain asks me directly why he isn't coming?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell him before he relies on you: "I won't give an illness explanation. Please send your availability yourself." You can do that without threatening to disclose his plans. It gives him time to send a straightforward message that he is unavailable, rather than building his excuse around your expected cooperation.

If the captain asks you why, "You'll need to ask him" can be enough. You can confirm only what you actually know and are responsible for communicating. Don't say "I have no idea" if you do know; keeping someone else's private detail private doesn't require another false statement.

The useful distinction is between supporting a teammate and supplying corroboration. You can help the captain get the availability answer in time, or remind your friend to send it. You don't have to become a witness for an invented illness to prove you are loyal.

It becomes more awkward if the captain says, "He told me you knew he was ill; is that right?" Redirecting alone might then sound like quiet confirmation. In that situation I would be quite explicit about not having confirmed that explanation, while avoiding an account of the social plan.

That is a sensible limit. "I haven't said he is ill. He needs to speak to you himself" corrects the use of your name. You needn't fill the silence with his actual plans. Afterwards, tell your teammate clearly that he must not cite you as support for a false explanation.

Join the discussion

More in Sports