Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

A seller won't open a sealed Pokémon pack to prove it's real. What is reasonable to ask?

Gaming category photographGaming

I asked a seller to open one of their sealed Pokémon packs so I could see what was inside. They said they wanted to sell it sealed. My friend called that proof it was fake; I can also see why a genuine seller wouldn't want to open the item for someone who hasn't agreed to buy it.

Pokémon Support's counterfeit guidance says fake booster packs can be difficult to distinguish and suggests that specialist card shops may be able to evaluate potentially counterfeit cards. That doesn't authenticate this seller's packs.

What checks could I reasonably request, and when is it better to pass? I want to be careful about the purchase without treating refusal of my first suggestion as evidence of fraud.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask for clear packaging photographs and relevant purchase information, while recognising that photographs may not settle authenticity. The official guidance itself warns that distinguishing fake packs can be difficult.

Keeping a sealed product sealed is a plausible reason for refusing your request. That doesn't establish authenticity either; it just means the refusal alone isn't enough to support your friend's accusation.

Decide what uncertainty you're willing to accept before negotiating further. You can decline a purchase without proving that the seller did anything wrong.

If you seek a specialist opinion, first ask whether the shop can assess this kind of sealed product and what that assessment would cover. Don't promise the seller a conclusive check that nobody has agreed to provide.

And if that route can't resolve the uncertainty, passing remains an option. An inconclusive assessment doesn't become proof in either direction, and you don't have to force a purchase to justify the time already spent considering it.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming