A regular wants their usual game-night seat after I've already offered it to someone else
GamingA regular in our four-player board-game group couldn't make several recent nights. For this Saturday I asked in the chat who was coming, heard nothing from them, and offered the fourth seat to a newcomer. The newcomer accepted and has arranged their evening around it.
Now the regular says they're free and assumes their usual place is available. We never agreed that the seat was reserved, but I also never set a reply deadline. The chosen game only seats four, and changing the plan now would mean asking the other confirmed players too.
I don't want to withdraw an invitation because someone more familiar became available. How should I explain this Saturday's decision while acknowledging that our invitation system has been vague?