Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

A player wants private role-playing scenes between every session. How much extra game-master time should I offer?

Gaming category photographGaming

His message began, "Can we play out the conversation tonight?" It was the third evening that week he'd asked for a private scene after our regular campaign session.

I'm the game master for a hobby group. I enjoy his interest in the world and have answered short character questions between meetings. Those answers have gradually become extra scenes, new contacts and information I need to remember when everyone returns.

The other players aren't asking for the same attention. I haven't checked how they feel about important events happening privately, and I can't keep adding evenings simply because the new scene sounds interesting.

What scope would you set? I'd like him to keep bringing ideas, with a clear distinction between sending an idea and receiving another session on demand. I also want a shared understanding of what belongs in the campaign everyone has time to attend.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell him which kinds of between-session input you enjoy receiving and what you aren't available to run. He may have read your earlier replies as an open invitation because the boundary was never stated.

Let an idea wait for the next group session when it needs actual play. You can appreciate the proposed conversation without promising to act it out the evening it arrives.

Discuss private developments with the group at an appropriate level, preserving any agreed story secrets. They should understand the arrangement that shapes the campaign, even if they don't know every character's information.

Choose a manageable way to handle brief questions, then keep longer scenes outside that promise. You could collect intentions and answer them when preparing the next session, if that suits how you work.

Hold that scope when an interesting question starts becoming a full encounter. Say where you'll pick it up rather than keep replying until the evening has disappeared. A limit you can use is kinder than agreeing enthusiastically and later resenting the player.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming