Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

A golf ball was found after we thought the search time had expired. How do I raise the rule without accusing my friend?

Sports category photographSports

"We've found it now, so I can play it," my friend said. We were in a club stroke-play competition, and I thought the permitted search time had already run out. No replacement ball had been played while we discussed what to do.

I don't want to decide the timing from irritation or accuse him of cheating. I do want us to ask an official rather than agree privately that finding the ball settles everything.

The R&A's Rule 18.2a says a ball is lost if it isn't found within three minutes after the player or caddie starts searching. It also distinguishes finding a ball in time from taking reasonable additional time to identify it.

What facts should I explain to the referee or Committee? I want to establish when searching began and when the ball was first found, then follow the ruling, rather than invent a penalty or treat friendship as a reason not to ask.

Discussion

5 community replies

Raise it while the situation can still be clarified: "I'm unsure whether the search time had expired; can we ask the official before proceeding?" Give the account you can support, including any uncertainty about the start or discovery time. Don't turn an estimate into a timestamp you didn't record.

The distinction about identification matters. A ball found during the allowed search period may take reasonable further time to identify under Rule 18.2a. That is different from first locating it after the period has ended. Ask which sequence actually occurred here.

You can value the friendship and still use the competition's process. "I don't know the correct ruling" is an honest reason to ask, and gives your friend room to explain what he remembers without answering a public allegation.

Would agreeing to let him play it be a reasonable kindness in a charity or friendly event? Some groups use relaxed formats, but I wouldn't assume the players can rewrite an entered stroke-play competition once a difficult situation appears.

Check the event's actual terms and use its officials for a ruling. An agreed casual format is a different arrangement, chosen openly beforehand. Here, don't replace a competition decision with a private favour, and don't assume a particular penalty before the official establishes the facts.

Join the discussion

More in Sports