Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

A friend wants to quote my private prototype feedback on their game's page. What should we agree?

Gaming category photographGaming

After trying a friend's unfinished board game, I wrote that one mechanism was promising and then described the parts I couldn't yet follow. They have now asked to use 'promising' beside my gaming handle on the public project page.

I want to support their work, but I wasn't writing a recommendation for buyers. The mechanism interested me; the whole game is still something they are developing. My friend thinks those distinctions can be handled by calling it playtest feedback.

What would you want to see before agreeing to a quote? I'd like to help without lending a broader endorsement than the comment was meant to give.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask to see the complete proposed wording, attribution and placement. One accurate word can carry a different message when it sits beside a purchase invitation rather than inside a page of private feedback.

You can distinguish praise for the mechanism from a recommendation of the whole game. That gives your friend something specific to understand rather than a vague objection to being quoted.

Check whether you are comfortable connecting this handle to the project publicly. Agreement about the words and agreement about the attribution are separate choices.

You may decide you would rather keep all the feedback private. Supporting the prototype doesn't require supplying a public quote, even if you genuinely liked parts of it.

And if you do agree to one particular use, make that scope clear. A sentence approved for a playtest section shouldn't quietly become a new statement attributed to you somewhere else without another conversation.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming