Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

A friend wants house rules before our first play. Is asking to try the printed version reasonable?

Gaming category photographGaming

Before we opened the board-game box, a friend suggested removing the negotiation round because they dislike bargaining games. I had invited everyone to try this particular game and wanted to see how its parts worked together before changing it.

My friend isn't trying to spoil the evening. They are telling us about a part they expect not to enjoy. I don't know yet whether removing it would leave a game any of us wants to play, and I don't want to present the printed rules as a reason they must sit through an evening they already dread.

Would you offer an agreed trial of the standard game, choose something else, or try the alteration? The invitation said we'd explore a new game together, not that everyone had committed to finishing it whatever happened.

Discussion

5 community replies

A trial of the printed version is a reasonable offer if the group wants it. Make the stopping point real rather than use 'just try it' to mean that everyone is now committed to the whole game.

Ask what your friend dislikes about negotiation. If it is the activity itself rather than a misunderstanding of this game, explaining the rules more enthusiastically may not change the choice.

Nobody needs to prove that the proposed house rule is bad to choose another game tonight. You can save this one for people who are interested in trying its standard form.

If you do test the alteration, describe the evening as playing that version. Don't treat a disappointing result as proof that the unmodified game fails in exactly the same way.

A fun result wouldn't require you to keep the change forever, either. It can be an enjoyable experiment for this group, with another agreement if you later want to explore the printed version.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming