Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

A friend says the company was awful when she worked there. The job I want is in another team.

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

A friend heard I'm interviewing at her former employer and told me not to go near it. She left three years ago after a difficult time with her manager. I believe her account and don't want to minimise it.

The vacancy is in another department, and the person who would manage me joined after she left. The work looks relevant to what I want next. My friend says that doesn't matter because the whole company culture was the problem.

I haven't accepted anything. How do I take her warning seriously while finding out about the current team? I'd like questions that go beyond asking an interviewer whether the culture is good, but I don't want to repeat my friend's private experience or ask her to prove that it was bad enough.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask your friend which aspects she thinks would still be relevant to your prospective role, if she's comfortable discussing them. Distinguish what she experienced directly from what either of you is assuming about the current team. You don't need to challenge her account to make that distinction.

Turn concerns into questions about actual practice: how priorities are set, what happens when work slips, how managers give feedback and why the vacancy exists. Ask for examples rather than inviting a general claim that the culture is excellent.

You could request a conversation with a prospective teammate through the recruitment process. Treat that as one more source of information, not a guarantee. Don't identify your friend as the reason for every question or share details she told you privately.

Would continuing with the interview feel disloyal when your friend has warned you so strongly? She may think you're dismissing what happened.

Tell her that you believe what happened to her and appreciate knowing it. You can also explain that you need to assess this particular role before deciding. Listening seriously doesn't require handing over the whole decision, and you don't need her to endorse your eventual choice for her account to matter.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work