Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

A friend assumes we’ll pair up on the next project, but another colleague’s strengths fit it better

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

“Same team again, then?” my friend said when the two-person project was announced.

We’ve worked well together on creative jobs. This assignment is mostly organising records, checking a long list of details and keeping a fixed handover sequence. Another colleague has offered to work with me and is particularly good at that sort of structure.

My friend is capable. I don’t want to turn one choice into a judgment that she’s unreliable or less valuable. I also know I’m considering staying with the familiar pairing partly to avoid an uncomfortable conversation.

The manager asked me to suggest a partner; nobody has been assigned yet.

How would you choose and explain it? Should I talk to my friend before making the recommendation, or keep the decision with the manager and avoid giving her a personal account of why someone else fits this job?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with what this project requires and the relevant strengths of the proposed partner. You’re recommending a combination for one assignment, not ranking two colleagues as people. Keep the explanation specific enough that it doesn’t become a vague claim that someone else is simply better.

If your friend expects the usual pairing, a brief conversation before the announcement may be kind. You don’t have to ask her permission for your recommendation. Say you’re proposing a different pairing because this job needs a particular kind of organisation, while acknowledging that you’ve enjoyed the work you’ve done together.

Check that the other colleague is available for the actual workload, not just interested in the idea. The manager still has to make the allocation. Don’t promise either person a place while trying to make the social conversation easier.

Only suggest a three-person arrangement if the work genuinely calls for it and the manager can support it. Adding a role to avoid disappointing a friend could make the project less clear and leave one person with an invented task.

That’s the useful test: would you propose the third role if there were no awkward conversation to avoid? If not, keep the recommendation straightforward. Your friend may be disappointed, and that doesn’t automatically mean you chose badly or need to redesign the project to remove the feeling.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work