Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

A borrowed board game is missing a counter, and I didn't check it when I collected it

Gaming category photographGaming

While packing a game I borrowed from the club library, I noticed a counter was missing. I checked the table, the bags and the box compartments without finding it. I hadn't counted the pieces when I collected the game, so I don't know whether it was already absent.

I want to report it before the next person borrows the box. I'm also worried that explaining the uncertainty will sound as though I'm trying to avoid responsibility. There wasn't a condition check at the handover.

What would be a useful message and next step? I want the game usable again without claiming certainty about when the counter disappeared.

Discussion

5 community replies

Report exactly what you found, where you've checked and that you didn't verify the contents at collection. That is clearer than either accusing the previous borrower or asserting that the piece definitely wasn't lost during your loan.

Let the library check whether the missing counter was already noted elsewhere. Don't turn your lack of a starting count into proof for either explanation.

Ask what replacement or temporary substitute would suit this particular game before buying a component at random. The library may already have a preferred way to handle an incomplete set.

For future loans, suggest a brief shared condition check at collection and return. Keep it practical for the game rather than a demand to audit every borrower as though a dispute has already begun.

That would give the next handover information this one lacked. It still wouldn't identify who lost the current counter, so keep the repair conversation separate from assigning blame the records can't support.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming